Back to SMGJohn's Profile SMGJohn's Profile

May 11, 2026
Mixed Feelings
Ranma ½ 2024 is an okay adaptation of the original manga.
A lot of people obviously wants to compare this to the original 80s anime adaptation however I think it can be said with certainty that both adaptations can exist in the same room - and its very obvious that the original Ranma ½ 1989 is a much more artistic, bombastic and energetic adaptation the opening and ending musics are classic examples.

However its important to understand that Ranma ½ 2024 is entirely its own thing and the only thing they share is the original source material, the manga.
With that in mind watching the ...
Apr 19, 2026
Yawara! (Anime) add
Yawara! Is one of those anime series that shows up on “Top 10 greatest 80s sports anime” however calling it merely a sports anime does not do it justice.

Yawara is perhaps the most underrated late 80s anime in the western hemisphere - it even surpassed Ranma in screen views at the time, its well known in Japanese circles and for good reasons, Yawara is not merely an anime about judo, its an anime about a clumsy and emotional teenage girl journey to find herself in the adult world her frustrations with judo not for the sport but because of her family which will hit ...
Apr 19, 2026
Kage no Jitsuryokusha ni Naritakute is one of those series that requires a specific mindset to enjoy, one that does not take itself too serious in life, someone who enjoys chaos and Japanese parody humour.

In 2022 when this aired on TV, I rated it quite poorly, a 3/10 after its last episode. However today, I rate it 7/10 – why? On paper in 2022, this was right up my ballpark but for some reasons when I was employed, a Corporate drone – life had simply made me dull and then 2 years later I was made redundant. Another 2 years passed and I decided on ...
Feb 5, 2026
Mixed Feelings
Every review is subjective, art is subjective your opinion may differ, never trust reviews to make the opinion for you, use them as a guide and make your own journey.
--
Firefighting in animation has always been a niche topic, and the original Megumi no Daigo manga stood out precisely because it combined credible operational detail with gripping drama. Rescuer in Orange inherits that legacy, and on paper it does with a solid continuation and more grounded, procedure oriented approach. The anime adaption however, feels more like a misfire than a controlled burn.

As a televised anime it functions, but only in the most technical sense. The production ...
Feb 5, 2026
Every review is subjective, art is subjective your opinion may differ, never trust reviews to make the opinion for you, use them as a guide and make your own journey.
--
Senjou no Valkyria, the anime adaptation of the game of the same title, makes its origins unmistakably clear. The source material is a strong tactical title that combines inventive gameplay systems with a serviceable narrative. Once stretched into a 26 episode television format, however - the adaptation exposes significant weaknesses in pacing, narrative cohesion and overall directorial judgement.

The series frequently plays like a string of disconnected cut scenes. In the game, the player fills the narrative ...
Jan 24, 2026
Mixed Feelings
Every review is subjective, art is subjective your opinion may differ, never trust reviews to make the opinion for you, use them as a guide and make your own journey.
--
Blessed with a remarkable soundtrack by Yoko Kanno, yet burdened by excessive symbolism and opaque abstraction, Arjuna is an anime that consistently prioritises political messaging over narrative engagement. While it is entirely possible for a work to successfully balance ideological critique with entertainment, it is equally reasonable for viewers to respond unfavourably when that balance collapses, as it does here.

At its conceptual core, Arjuna seeks to critique gratuitous consumption within a commercialised society and to highlight ...
Jan 10, 2026
Every review is subjective, art is subjective your opinion may differ, never trust reviews to make the opinion for you, use them as a guide and make your own journey.
--
When I first watched Carole & Tuesday in 2019, my assessment was unremarkable. It was competent, neither especially impressive nor notably poor. Revisiting it several years later, however, in a period defined by the rapid normalisation of generative AI and algorithmically produced music, the series presents itself rather differently.

What once appeared to be a speculative premise now feels distinctly contemporary. Carole & Tuesday was among the earlier mainstream anime to pose a clear question: what happens ...
Jan 10, 2026
Lazarus (Anime) add
Every review is subjective, art is subjective your opinion may differ, never trust reviews to make the opinion for you, use them as a guide and make your own journey.
--

There are certain anime that provoke unusually polarised reactions, attracting both strong admiration and outright dismissal. This pattern appears most often with works aimed at the seinen demographic, particularly those that draw stylistic influence from the so called golden age of anime. Lazarus sits squarely within this tradition. It is both a seinen series and one whose direction consciously echoes the tone and pacing of 1990s adult oriented productions.

Lazarus does not rely on spectacle driven action ...
Nov 12, 2025
Mixed Feelings
FunnyFunny
Every review is subjective, art is subjective your opinion may differ, never trust reviews to make the opinion for you, use them as a guide and make your own journey.
--
Dr. Stone Season 4: From Science Project to Saturday Morning Noise Machine

Many viewers who fell in love with Dr. Stone during its first season have now had to confront an uncomfortable reality. What began as a science driven survival story has steadily drifted into full battle shounen territory, and by Season 4 the transformation is complete. The tonal shift that started in Season 3 has now settled firmly into kodomomuke territory, with all the subtlety and ...
Aug 12, 2025
"Isekai Nonbiri Nouka" A Masterclass in Conflict-Free Comfort

If you have ever wondered what it would look like to take Stardew Valley, strip it of its emotional depth, interpersonal nuance, and gameplay challenge, and then pump it full of inexplicably devoted women, Isekai Nonbiri Nouka might be just the relaxing viewing experience you did not know you were not looking for.

The story follows our hero an aggressively unbothered man who is generously gifted a second life where struggle is apparently a myth. In this alternate world, he builds a farm with the kind of ease that would make real farmers cry. Tools? Mastered instantly. Resources? Always ...


It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login